PICTURE BOOKS
Picture Book Judging Please rate your book according to the following Children’s Book Council of Australia (CBCA) criteria. A maximum of 5 points can be given for each criterion. Book #1 – Title / Author: the little house/ Virginia lee burton Criterion Score (05) Artistic style and graphic excellence (including typography and its suitability for the implied readership) Comments: 3. It's very thoughtful for children to think about the economy nowadays. Effective use of media and technique Comments: 3. This book wants to tell the revolution of economy and its bud and sad points. It's very thoughtful for everyone. Color, line, shape, texture Comments: 4. there are beautiful colored pictures and they are very easy for children to understand the story. also, texts are deviced and they fit the pictures well. Relationship between illustration and text Comments: 4. they suit together very well. texts are in the pictures. it is very unique and artistic. Consistency of style, characterization, information and setting Comments: 4. this story is about a house. and the house is called She, so in the story, the house is like a girl. it is interesting we thought. Clarity appropriateness and aesthetic appeal of illustrations Comments: 4 the pictures are drawn by paint so there are no lines. we think it is artistic and it makes the story warm. Quality of book design, production, printing and binding Comments:4 it is little bit sad story, but very thoughtful story. its appropriate length and contents for 5~7 years old General Comments: (Including qualities or merits of the book not captured by the above criteria): we like this story, pictures, and contents. its very thoughtful story and children can study developments of the economy and the bad pounts of them. Media English 2014/Nelson 2 Picture Book Judging Please rate your book according to the following Children’s Book Council of Australia (CBCA) criteria. A maximum of 5 points can be given for each criterion. Book #2 – Title / Author:Badger's parting gift / Susan varley Criterion Score (05) Artistic style and graphic excellence (including typography and its suitability for the implied readership) Comments:5 pictures of this book is clear. Effective use of media and technique Comments:4 some pages write passage just half. Color, line, shape, texture Comments:4 3 colors is good but we couldn't see clearly shape. Relationship between illustration and text Comments:5 between illustration and text are excellent. Consistency of style, characterization, information and setting Comments:5 good, just good Clarity appropriateness and aesthetic appeal of illustrations Comments:3 I think it's not appropriate well. Quality of book design, production, printing and binding Comments: General Comments: (Including qualities or merits of the book not captured by the above criteria): it's good for children to read because it's not too long or too short. Media English 2014/Nelson |